Hydrogen Fuel Cell Technology: the promise and the challenges

Last Wednesday, we welcomed Amanda Lyne (left), Founder and Managing Director at ULEMCo Ltd, to the Victory Lounge for our monthly discussion. Her topic was 

Hydrogen and Fuel Cells - a route to low carbon energy for transport, heat and electricity

Not only is  Amanda the Founder of ULEMCo Ltd, but she is also, Deputy Chair of the UK Hydrogen and Fuel Cell Association, Director of the Liverpool City Region Local Enterprise Partnership and chair of its Low Carbon Economy Committee. Amanda began by introducing herself. From an early educational background in Science, she made the transition to the commercial world through periods at ICI followed by a move to the early stage company Micap (which was one of the first Biotech ventures in Merseyside to raise funds through an IPO on AIM). This has been followed by a sustained period in the "Energy sector", hence her topic for the presentation.

Fuel cell technology (FCT), isn't new. As Amanda pointed out it was originally proposed during the great era of Victorian Science by the Welsh Physicist and Barrister, William Grove (only in the mid 19th Century could you claim to be both!). The idea took off (literally!) during the second world war when Francis Bacon (not the early advocate of scientific method), developed the first practical fuel cell, called the alkaline fuel cell in which the input Hydrogen undergoes a redox reaction to yield electrons, followed by recombination of the protons with oxygen to produce water. The explanation at the wiki site is (in my view) a pretty good summary of Amanda's explanation of the principles underpinning the technology. However, the designs that have grown out of the original devices (notably deployed by NASA in the space shuttle) are now much more sophisticated and have been incorporated into a number of vehicles. Indeed, Amanda devoted the next part of her talk describing both the developments, the logistics and the challenges ahead for the commercial uptake of FCT.

The use of FCT (in particular hydrogen based, but Amanda did include a mention of methanol FCs, in some applications) in the automotive industry, resonated with the audience, who raised questions concerning the commercial viability (the economics and logistics) as well as the risks associated with driving around with a tank of liquid hydrogen. Amanda gave a well balanced evaluation of the comparative risks and the pros and cons of Lithium battery powered cars, such as the new Tesla (which she has taken on a test drive, to the envy of some of the audience!)


Amanda finished the talk with examples of FTC in action today, which was reinforced by images of not only vehicles, but examples of marine and a range of industrial applications, as well as her company's long term approach to providing sustainable solutions for more widespread introduction of the technology alone or as a hybrid solution. This led to a long and interesting discussion relating to the politics and economics, as well as the practicalities of fuelling stations etc. On the whole, it provided an engaged and audience (as always at the Widnes SciBar) with plenty to think about as we try to come to terms with managing the global challenges of sustainable energy supply and consumption.

Thanks Amanda, the Friends of Catalyst and everyone who made it to the Hillcrest, for making it another enjoyable and stimulating meeting!

Bob will be circulating further details of next month's talk, which takes us to the challenges facing the scientists exploring the frozen southern oceans! Fitting for this time of the year!

Preview: The Science Behind Ebola: plugging gaps in our knowledge as we battle the disease

Ebola virus continues to wreak havoc in West Africa, as you can see on the left, late summer into September saw the virus enter an exponential phase with respect to the death toll. You may recall the statistics of HIV in the 1980s-90s, or even earlier the number of deaths caused by Polio before vaccination was introduced. All of these examples have one thing in common: we wait until we are in the fiercest phase of infection before we start producing a cure, whether it is a vaccine, a drug or in the case of microbes, an antibiotic. However, in order to develop something effective, we need to know more about the virus, and this is where we not only learn how to eradicate it, but we have also come to value the insight that studying mechanisms of disease. I am going to discuss the knowledge we have gained from virology, that will ultimately help us in the war against cancer and infectious diseases, but has also informed our fundamental understanding of the molecular basis of life. 

I shall begin with the concepts underpinning mutation rates and evolution that emerged from the work of Luria and Delbruck on bacteriophage. Then I shall consider how viruses utilise different strategies to infect and replicate. The realisation that many of the viruses that pose the greatest threat to life are based on RNA and not DNA, was critical in identifying the genes that when mutated can cause cancer. On the other hand, the fact that armed with just a handful of genes, a prolific ability to replicate them, together with an intrinsically high level of mutation, are all at the heart of the deadly nature of HIV and Ebola. Along the way, I shall also bring out the advances in our knowledge of the molecular basis of life that have emerged from studying viruses.

Note added, the talk is accessible as a Google slide show (LHS) and the information on phage therapy can be found for starters at this wiki site. Thanks for the challenging and enjoyable discussion!

WWI and Chemistry in Britain and Germany

Last Wednesday, Emeritus Professor Alan Dronsfield FRSC (currently based at the University of Derby), delivered a timely lecture entitled "The First World War - Its Chemical Origins". Alan outlined the complexity of both the causes of the war and the alliances on each side. He described World War I as the war of the chemists, with World War II being the war of the physicists. Both sides in the conflict were confident they would win fairly quickly. Alan suggested that no nation declares war unless it is confident it will win. The Allies believed that, being largely land locked, they would be able to blockade Germany, thereby eliciting their surrender.

In particular it was considered an easy option to block the shipment of Chile saltpetre between Germany and Chile, traditionally a vital ingredient in the manufacture of fertilisers and explosives, cordite in particular. Whilst poison gases are often associated with WWI, Alan said that in terms of deaths, they had a much smaller impact than contemporary developments in shells, bullets and explosives chemistry.

Shells and Bullets Major-General Henry Shrapnel (1761–1842), an English artillery officer, developed an artillery shell that had a timer device that was set to break open the shell at a specified time after being fired, releasing small metal balls in all directions. When fired in a high trajectory by howitzers, and with the shell exploding just above the ground, these proved to be lethal weapons in trench warfare; traditional shells that exploded on impact with the ground were generally less devastating.  The development of cordite facilitated the development of high precision fuses for the first time, which enabled a gun crew to adjust the timing of the fuse according to what happened with the first few shells, with the aim of timing the explosion to coincide with their exploding just above trenches. German forces redesigned the components of the shells to maximise their impact. Due to the development of the ‘all in one’ bullet a rifleman could shoot far quicker than the twice per minute of a good rifleman in previous centuries. The introduction of the machine gun was a means of firing the ‘modern’ bullet at a very high rate.

Chemistry Contrary to the British strategy of blocking German access to the raw materials for the fabrication of explosives, Germany became self-sufficient in vital supplies through its vibrant chemical industry. After Perkins made the first synthetic dye derived from coal tar, a key commercial target was the synthesis of the red dye, Madder - for centuries the Madder shrub that grows in southern Europe had been a source of this deep red dye. At this point in the proceedings, Alan enlisted the help of a keen young member of the audience for a "hands on" demonstration of dying wool and silk. The experiment was a great success, and nobody was hurt during the process!

Progress in the synthesis of dyes wasn’t helped by the limited understanding of chemical notation and a consensus estimate of atomic weights - whilst John Dalton had advanced our understanding in 1803, he also caused confusion, e.g. was water HO or HOH?The Karlsruhe Congress in 1860 was an attempt to bring some order to these issues, but it closed without general agreement. However, ideas proposed by Cannizzaro were picked up by Meyer, a German chemist, and this was instrumental in bringing order and predictability to industrial synthesis in particular.

With alizarin having already been identified as an active ingredient in Madder, the new structural formalism helped German chemists Grabe and Libermann, working for BASF, to find a way, in 1868 to synthesise alizarin from anthracene, and at a fraction of the cost of the natural product. This proved to be a milestone in the international dye industry and triggered a major development of the chemical industry in Germany; at the time few of the best brains in Britain were attracted to chemistry: Academia being too lofty for contemplating the "applied sciences"!

This industrial lead was further advanced when in 1909 Fritz Haber discovered how to manufacture ammonia from the nitrogen in air, thereby providing a means of producing fertiliser, nitric acid and explosives. This process undermined the Allies’ hopes of a blockade of Chile saltpetre, hastening a German surrender.  During WW1 Haber was an enthusiastic advocate of chemical warfare and directed German research seeking improvements in poison gases. For example, he sought chemicals that weren’t absorbed by the filter in gas masks as was the case with chlorine. One approach was to disperse arsenical powders that would pass through a gas mask and cause sickness. Then the gas would get you!In 1918 Haber was awarded the Nobel Prize, a controversial decision because of his work on poison gases during WW1. Although the allies all had active chemical warfare programmes as well. Alan spoke about him being a German patriot who, because he was Jewish, emigrated in 1934 with the build-up of National Socialism in Germany, only to die a few months later in Switzerland after a short sojourn in England.

Alan finished his presentation by dramatically illustrating the nature of WW1 warfare with a series of photographs and slides of poetry written about warfare. This was a very moving finale to a fascinating talk.

Bob Roach and Dave Hornby

Welcome to the Widnes Sci Bar Blog Site

Ferdinand Hurter (1844-1898)

The Widnes Sci Bar provides the opportunity for anyone interested to listen and engage in lively discussions about aspects of contemporary Science and the History of Science (pictured left is Ferdinand Hurter, who pioneered the integration of research and applied chemistry during his time in Widnes; whilst finding time to turn photography from a hobby into a Science!). Presentations of around 40 minutes are delivered by those actively engaged in academic and industrial science, as well as speakers who have a genuine passion for Science from a wide range of backgrounds. The current venue is the Hillcrest Hotel on the road out of Widnes towards Cronton Village, close to Riverside College. 

The aim of this Blog site is to provide additional material, on an occasional basis, as well as providing a commentary on speakers, both in advance and as a forum for comments and any suggestions for speakers. We shall be adding to the site over the next few weeks (links and other material). We would also welcome any posts (and images) from members of the community who would like to share their thoughts and views on a suitable scientific topic. We shall also ask speakers if they are willing to provide the slide show presentations to upload onto the site to develop an archive, if you happen to miss a talk. This first Blog is by way of introduction and the second post will follow the next meeting on Wednesday the 12th November where, at the usual time of 7.30pm, Professor Alan Dronsfield of the Royal Society of Chemistry's Historical Group (and a trustee of the Catalyst Discovery Centre) will present a talk entitled:

The First World War - Its Chemical Origins 

We look forward to seeing you there and will follow up with a commentary shortly afterwards. Gas masks will be provided!

Best wishes Bob Roach (and Dave Hornby)